This summer, quarterback Matthew Stafford was a mid- to late-round pick in most fantasy football drafts, a far cry from where he was actually drafted back in 2009. For those of you who ignored his injury history and snagged him as your starter, enjoy reaping the benefits. For the rest who ended up drafting him as a backup in standard leagues and now have two elite quarterbacks, you are left with three options. You can trade Stafford, trade your other top quarterback, or keep them both. It is, after all, a long season, and Stafford’s an injury-prone player. At the very least you’ll have a solid backup and great bye week option.
I only condone trading Stafford if you have Drew Brees, Philip Rivers, Tom Brady, Michael Vick, or Aaron Rodgers on your team as well. If this is the case, trading Stafford is the best option, assuming you can get value for him. Stafford warrants a running back or receiver that will start on your team every week, so don’t settle for anything less. If nobody wants to make a deal, then keep your team intact and enjoy your depth at quarterback.
Trading your non-Stafford quarterback is a much bigger risk. Of the five elite quarterbacks I mentioned above, hold onto Rodgers, Brees, and Brady at all cost. With Vick and Rivers, it really comes down to what you can get in your particular league. There is undoubtedly an owner or two in your league struggling at the QB position. If you own Stafford along with either Vick or Rivers, the owner would probably be delighted to take one of them off your hands. The key is to find out which one he loves, and make him pay dearly.

Syracuse University sport management major and “fantasy guru” Kevin Hall thinks that good owners to target for a trade are those that have Ben Rothlisberger or Matt Schaub starting for their team. “Schaub is considerably less valuable without Andre Johnson and Rothlisberger’s injury on top of his poor play makes their owners the best to try to make a deal with,” explains Hall.
Of course if you decide to stick with Stafford as your QB option, keep his injury history in mind. There’s a reason he wasn’t drafted higher in fantasy leagues. Both of his first two seasons in the NFL ended early due to injury. In his rookie 2009 season he was only healthy enough to play 10 of 16 games. Last year, he took the field in just three. This year’s injury could be right around the corner, which makes trading him at peak value or keeping both quarterbacks the smart moves.
As Bleacher Report’s Ryan Campbell says, Stafford’s numbers don’t lie; he deserves to be a starter on someone’s team every week he’s healthy. So start fielding offers from the rest of your league. My guess is you will find something you like.